The article discusses elderly cardboard collectors in Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, China, and Taiwan, highlighting the paradox of poverty among senior citizens in affluent Asian societies.
Less than a decade ago, Hong Kong’s “cardboard grannies” were featured in the news, and people across the globe were shocked to learn about many elderly poor, especially women, collecting cardboard long hours each day to support themselves, in one of the richest cities in the world.
In 2017, after one of these “cardboard grannies” sold a cardboard box to a domestic helper for HK$1 , she was charged by the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department for selling without a license. After much public outcry, the case was dropped. Hong Kong has had the longest life expectancy of any city in the world, with an average lifespan of about 85.9 years.
However, among its senior citizens, around 580,000 live in poverty, according to a 2024 report from Oxfam Hong Kong.piece said that one of Hong Kong’s cardboard grannies earns HK$100 about each day , scarcely sufficient to pay for two meals. Lately, she’s been earning less, with recycling companies slashing their rates in half, and when the cardboard she collects is thrown away by mistake, she gets nothing at all.
In Singapore, there are karung guni aunties and uncles, older people who collect cardboard, cans, and scrap. Like Hong Kong, many find it shocking that the elderly have to work this way in such a rich society.
While Singapore has a substantially stronger social safety net than Hong Kong, especially when it comes to housing, subsidies, and cash supplementation, there are still concerns over the financial vulnerability of the elderly and their need to keep on working long past retirement age. South Korea’s problem of poverty among the elderly is among the highest in the OECD.
In China, elderly “ayi” recyclers are common, and in Taiwan, where the problem is not nearly as bad as in other places in Asia, many elderly people informally collect cardboard, cans, and recyclables. In a sense, Asia’s elderly poor may be seen as victims of success.
The incidence of poverty among senior citizens coincides with several factors, including rapid economic growth, ageing populations, weakening family support systems, and insufficient retirement adequacy for older generations who grew up before modern pension systems matured. The problem is not uniquely Asian, but wherever there is a gap between the cost of living and old-age income support, some elderly people end up doing informal survival work, including collecting recyclables, street vending, begging, and scavenging.
A Ghanaian man sat down with a Singaporean woman to talk about why Singaporeans complain so much, when so many things in the city-state actually work. Not that for Kojo Enoch, the content creator ... Baey Yam Keng branded ‘king of wayang’ for posting about 30 minute walk on the ground One netizen said,"30 minutes is frankly unacceptable. As Tampines TC Chairperson, we should be seeing at least 30 hours a week on the ground.
"document.addEventListener=>{ const trigger=document.getElementById; if { const observer=new IntersectionObserver=>{ entries.forEach { lazyLoader; // You should define lazyLoader elsewhere or inline here observer.unobserve; // Run once } }); }, { rootMargin: '800px', threshold: 0.1 }); observer.observe; } else { // Fallback setTimeout; } });
Please follow us on Google to support usElderly Poverty Cardboard Collectors Hong Kong Aging Population Social Safety Net
Singapore Latest News, Singapore Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Fathers' Parking Space Dispute Turns Ugly, Elderly Woman InjuredTwo fathers got into a fight over a parking space at a school in Singapore, resulting in an elderly woman being injured. One of the fathers has been fined $4,000 for disturbing the peace and criminal violence.
Read more »
US War Secretary urges Asian nations to increase defence spending at Shangri-La DialogueUS War Secretary Pete Hegseth called on Asian countries to spend more on their militaries during his plenary remarks at the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, emphasizing that the US will prioritize partners who contribute more to their own defence. He praised Australia, Japan, South Korea, and Vietnam for their increased budgets but notably omitted Taiwan, drawing criticism. He also reassured the region that US commitment remains strong despite Middle East conflicts.
Read more »
Elderly Malaysian Man Seeks Help for Late Wife's Funeral ExpensesAn elderly Malaysian man appeals for public donations to afford his late wife's funeral, sharing his story via activist Kuan Chee Heng. The plea highlights poverty among the elderly in Malaysia.
Read more »
Singapore names 256 athletes for provisional Asian Games squadSingapore has provisionally selected 256 athletes across 23 sports for the 2026 Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games, led by defending champions Shanti Pereira and Ryan Lo. Notable selections include badminton star Loh Kean Yew and swimmers from the Quah family, while football is excluded and sprinter Marc Brian Louis is omitted due to disciplinary reasons.
Read more »