Justine McCarthy: Judge Deirdre Murphy’s warning on our broken legal system must not be ignored

Singapore News News

Justine McCarthy: Judge Deirdre Murphy’s warning on our broken legal system must not be ignored
Singapore Latest News,Singapore Headlines
  • 📰 IrishTimes
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 45 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 21%
  • Publisher: 98%

Murphy’s assertion about legal fees has an ear-splitting ring of plausibility, and a disgusting stench of scandal

In a startling disclosure, Judge Murphy recalled being told when she was a senior counsel being offered a brief by one of the major solicitors’ firms that she did not charge a handsome enough fee, whereby the State effectively acts as a disinterested litigant obliged to uphold everybody’s rights. On Wednesday, a set of non-binding principles for State litigation was published, echoing this model, following Cabinet approval.

In a startling disclosure – one which some of her erstwhile colleagues at the bar may consider a betrayal of a professional secret – Judge Murphy recalled being told when she was a senior counsel being offered a brief by one of the major solicitors’ firms that she did not charge a handsome enough fee. “The bigger firms want to brief somebody who will charge a fortune so that they can justify charging a fortune,” she said.

“We’re talking about the people’s money,” Murphy said. “A fair and equitable distribution of State work will make the system better because work will be distributed among those capable of doing it and not just the favourites of particular people.” Ireland is an exceptionally litigious country with prohibitive costs that have turned the civil law courts into the domain of the State and wealthy individuals, at the expense of most citizens

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

IrishTimes /  🏆 3. in İE

Singapore Latest News, Singapore Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Gus McCarthy to lead Ireland in opening under-20 Championship tie against EnglandGus McCarthy to lead Ireland in opening under-20 Championship tie against EnglandGus McCarthy will reprise his role as captain when Ireland open their World Rugby Under-20 Championship campaign against England in South Africa on Saturday, while Max Clein is expected to make his debut with Richie Murphy’s side off the bench
Read more »

Former Dublin Lord Mayor and Labour politician among five High Court judge nomineesFormer Dublin Lord Mayor and Labour politician among five High Court judge nomineesNominations form part of long-awaited plans to add more judges to the justice system
Read more »

Former Dublin Lord Mayor and Labour politician among five High Court judge nomineesFormer Dublin Lord Mayor and Labour politician among five High Court judge nomineesNominations form part of long-awaited plans to add more judges to the justice system
Read more »

High court appoints liquidators to forestry firm amid fraud allegationsHigh court appoints liquidators to forestry firm amid fraud allegationsJudge appoints chartered accountants Jim Luby and Enda Lowry of McStay Luby as joint liquidators to GWD Forestry Ltd
Read more »

Protection of journalistic sources ‘integral’ to free press, Supreme Court rulesProtection of journalistic sources ‘integral’ to free press, Supreme Court rulesSeven-judge court unanimously agrees to dismiss Garda Commissioner’s appeal over access to journalist’s phone
Read more »

Online service providers to be subject to legal obligations to make internet saferOnline service providers to be subject to legal obligations to make internet saferBusinesses such as Google, Meta and Amazon will all be subject to the new rules being put in place by media regulator
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-08-27 23:32:37