Rishi Reddi's 'Passage West' plumbs an important story of Indian immigrant farmers, but isn't quite up to the task as fiction
, “Karma and Other Stories,” feel understated and effective; here, perhaps feeling compelled by the urgency of the story, she tips over into melodrama, dampening its impact.
Not long after his arrival, he’s beaten in a savage hate crime in Washington state. He decides to take his friend Karak up on his offer to join him on a cantaloupe farm. Karak’s uncle, Jivan, a Sikh, welcomes the Hindu Ram into the fold: “You are like my family to us; we are from branches of the same tree.” Ram spends days recovering from the injuries he suffered in the attack, although he hides the truth about the origin of his wounds.
There are certainly things to admire about “Passage West.” It’s a well researched novel about a time and place in American history that few outside Southern California likely know about, and Reddi does a very good job evoking the physical and political landscape of the early-20th century Imperial Valley. She’s particularly sharp on the effects of California’s Alien Land Laws, two xenophobic acts that prohibited many immigrants from owning farmland.
Then there is the melodrama. In one scene, Jivan, who fought for the British army, comes to a bizarrely sudden realization that the U.K. hasn’t been fair to the people of India, an opinion he previously resisted. In a scene that’s cinematic in the worst way, he throws his military medals into the Salton Sea. Not long afterward, Karak, who had cut his long hair in preparation for his marriage, makes a weirdly similar gesture, tossing his cut locks into the Colorado River.
Singapore Latest News, Singapore Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
'Defending Jacob': TV ReviewChris Evans, Michelle Dockery and Jaeden Martell star in an Apple TV+ drama about a seemingly perfect family that may or may not be harboring a killer.
Read more »
20 Products That Inspired Hundreds Of People To Leave A Five Star Review$3 acne spot gel, a chic lil' air fryer, a body pillow your body could melt right into, and way more.
Read more »
'Trials of Mana': Game Review'A lovingly-crafted remake of a classic many may have missed 25 years ago.' Read THR's review for TrialsofMana:
Read more »
‘Warhol’ Review: Nothing Like the Real ThingFrom WSJbooks: “Fame is the right measure of his achievement, but fame was not his only spur.” DrDominicGreen reviews BlakeGopnik’s “Warhol,” a book on the curious life of Andy Warhol.
Read more »