The lawyer for two ministers suing Bloomberg and one of its reporters over an allegedly defamatory article said the case is unprecedented for the malice directed at the ministers. The article published on Dec 12, 2024 mentions the ministers' property deals which took place in 2023.
The lawyer for two ministers suing Bloomberg and one of its reporters over an allegedly defamatory article said the case is unprecedented for the malice directed at Coordinating Minister for National Security K. Shanmugam and Manpower Minister Tan See Leng.
In closing submissions on May 22, Senior Counsel Davinder Singh said that ill-intent was illustrated in e-mails exchanged within the financial news organisation in the lead-up to the article, and in its decision to drop its paywall and provide access to the wider public, after it was issued with a correction direction under Singapore's fake news law. In summarising the claimant's case, Mr Singh said it was important to note the context in which Mr Shanmugam and Dr Tan are mentioned in the article "Singapore mansion deals are increasingly shrouded in secrecy", which was written by Mr Low De Wei.
He said an ordinary and reasonable reader in Singapore would have taken these mentions to falsely mean that the ministers took advantage of there being no checks and balances or disclosure requirements for their transactions, and that they wanted to hide their transactions and avoid scrutiny.
"This case is unprecedented for the malice, the determination to hurt and the aggravation," said Mr Singh. The article published on Dec 12, 2024 mentions the ministers' property deals which took place in 2023 - Mr Shanmugam's sale of his former home in the Queen Astrid Park area to UBS Trustees for $88 million, and Dr Tan's purchase of a bungalow in Brizay Park for nearly $27.3 million.
Bloomberg's lawyer, Senior Counsel N. Sreenivasan, said the news organisation has been consistent in its position and had employed the defence of responsible journalism to reflect the care it took in researching for the article. He said understanding the meaning of the article, as taken by an ordinary and reasonable reader, would require ignoring the "strained meaning" asserted by the claimants as well as their sensitivity.
Mr Sreenivasan and Senior Counsel Chelva Rajah, who is representing Mr Low, said there was nothing defamatory of Mr Shanmugam and Dr Tan in the article, which they described as a report on trends relating to the purchase of good class bungalows (GCBs) in Singapore. They said the article was extensively researched, and the information was verified through consultation with industry experts and communications with various government agencies.
The lawyers added that the ministers were each given "multiple opportunities" to comment. The lawyers said there was no suggestion in the article of any wrongdoing by the ministers, and it makes no allegation against them. They said Mr Shanmugam and Dr Tan were mentioned only briefly in the article. In his submissions, Mr Singh challenged the defendants' claim that the article was about the increasing GCB prices and purchases by wealthy foreigners and naturalised citizens.
He said that if that were really the case, there would be no reason to feature Mr Shanmugam, who was a seller and not a buyer, in the article. Yet, it devoted multiple paragraphs to Mr Shanmugam's transaction and even described it as having become "political fodder".
Mr Singh said he is leaving it to the court to decide on the quantum of damages it would ask from Bloomberg and Mr Low, but added that it should be higher than what was awarded in the defamation case against The Online Citizen (TOC) chief editor Terry Xu. In that case, the High Court had on March 31 granted $160,000 in general damages each to Mr Shanmugam and Mr Tan, for a TOC article which referred to the Bloomberg piece on property transactions.
Mr Singh noted that Bloomberg has a wider viewership than TOC, and is "immeasurably far better known and established". He said that in the case involving Mr Xu, the High Court had also granted $50,000 each in aggravated damages. Mr Singh said that with the "unprecedented" aggravation in the present case, and the conduct of the defendants, this amount should be far higher. He said the defence had "behaved reprehensibly" by "withholding material documents" from the court and claimants.
Mr Singh added that in the lead-up to trial, the defendants had withheld and then "drip fed" documents, despite orders from the court.
"It is also clear that (Bloomberg) is not at all concerned about the implications of aggravation. It has deep pockets.
"Based on the objective facts, it is clear that its aim is to maximise the publicity and further embarrass and damage (the claimants)," Mr Singh said. Mr Sreenivasan and Mr Rajah said that if the judge rules the article as defamatory, damages to be awarded to the ministers should not exceed $80,000 each. They said it takes into account the totality of the circumstances and, in particular, the nature and gravity of the allegedly offending words and the defendants' conduc
Defamation Bloomberg Reporter Minister Property Deals Queen Astrid Park Brizay Park Aggravation Deep Pockets Maximise Publicity Embarassment Damage Unprecedented Malice Determination To Hurt Aggravation Unreasonable Reader Context Transactions Checks And Balances Disclosure Requirements Garbage In Garbage Out Responsible Journalism Researching Consultation With Industry Experts Communications With Various Government Agencie Multiple Opportunities No Wrongdoing Brief Mention Garbage Out Garbage In Responsible Journalism Researching Consultation With Industry Experts Communications With Various Government Agencie Multiple Opportunities No Wrongdoing Brief Mention Garbage Out Garbage In Responsible Journalism Researching Consultation With Industry Experts Communications With Various Government Agencie Multiple Opportunities No Wrongdoing Brief Mention
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Commentary: Prabowo’s Indonesia is teetering toward a familiar disasterBewildering policies and authoritarian tendencies by President Prabowo Subianto are steering Indonesia toward a mix of currency instability and political chaos, says Karishma Vaswani for Bloomberg Opinion.
Read more »
Regulators question StanChart following CEO Winters' AI comments amid job cuts, Bloomberg News reportsHong Kong and Singapore regulators have sought clarity from Standard Chartered after CEO Bill Winters said the global lender plans to replace 'lower-value human capital' with technology, Bloomberg News reported on Thursday (May 21).
Read more »
Senior Counsel Reminds Court of Bloomberg's Role in GCB Transaction FalsificationHome Affairs Minister K Shanmugam and Manpower Minister Tan See Leng's defamation suit against Bloomberg and reporter Low De Wei was continued; Senior Counsel Davinder Singh, who represents the two ministers, urged the court to reject the defendants' argument that the article was merely about publicly known information regarding GCB transactions. He stated that it contained calls for stronger checks and balances and mandatory disclosure rules, which were not directed at the public. The defendants argued that the claimants were advancing the most defamatory meaning conceivable, while their case was based on a 'plain and ordinary' reading of the article. The trial stems from an article titled 'Singapore Mansion Deals Are Increasingly Shrouded in Secrecy' published on Bloomberg's website on Dec 12, 2024.
Read more »
Singapore's Economic Success: Lessons from Kishore MahbubaniIn a Bloomberg interview, Mahbubani marvels at Singapore's rise from extreme poverty to one of the highest-income nations in the world. He attributes their success to the leadership of three remarkable geopolitical geniuses.
Read more »